[Measure 92] seeks to require food producers and manufacturers to clearly label any genetically modified foods. While we like the idea of knowing what we’re eating, we can’t support the ballot measure as it’s written.
Opponents have called the measure “overreaching” and “poorly written,” both statements we agree with.
To the first point, establishing an Oregon-specific rule regarding GMO labeling puts growers and producers across the state at a disadvantage when going head to head with growers from other states and other countries. We’re not competing against other Oregonians when we sell our crops. For the most part, we’re competing against other states and against other countries.
A recent editorial in Salem’s Statesman Journal put it this way: “Product labeling is a national and global issue, and that is where the requirements should be established.” We agree. Why give Oregon farmers a burden that could put them at a competitive disadvantage — especially when that burden is not clearly outlined?
If it passes, Measure 92 will require any raw food packaged for retail sale to include the words “genetically engineered,” “produced with genetic engineering” or “partially produced with genetic engineering” to appear conspicuously on any GMO foods. That labeling only applies to food intended for human consumption. A rancher could purchase genetically modified feed for his cattle; if that feed isn’t labeled, how would he know? And would he still be responsible for feeding the public beef “partially produced with genetic engineering”?
… Under the measure, “any injured citizen” could sue producers over labeling. In a recent letter to the editor, Ontario-area farmer Dana Tuckness said the measure “creates a new class for bounty hunter lawsuits.” Large operations have lawyers on retainer to deal with potential lawsuits. Small growers bringing produce to the local farmers market do not.
Measure 92 brings another level of bureaucracy to farming. Federal agencies already monitor food safety. This measure would add another set of hoops for farmers to jump through.
